PFBI Case Studies

< Back

U-HAUL AND THE SHOENS – A SHATTERED DYNASTY

Source : Family Wars - Grant Gordon & Nigel Nicholson

Origins and Entrepreneurial Journey

Leonard Samuel (L.S.) Shoen, who grew up in poverty, founded U-Haul, a nationwide trailer rental business. Despite his humble beginnings, L.S. persevered and transitioned from doing menial work to getting enrolled in medical school, and his determination paved the way for U-Haul’s remarkable success. The catalyst for U-Haul’s inception came from his personal experience when a need to relocate trailers inspired him to establish a Fleet Owner Program, a key factor in U-Haul’s growth.

Family Life and Loss

In his 20s, L.S. met his first love interest, Anna Mary. And despite her heart condition, L.S. married her, resulting in the birth of six children. Tragically, Anna’s passing in 1957 had a profound impact on the family, causing both emotional and financial upheaval. L.S.’s unconventional parenting style and subsequent marriage to Suzanne only exacerbated the turmoil within the family, contributing to their divisions.

Siblings and Business Conflict

L.S.’s ambition for all his sons to work at U-Haul created conflict and division among them. The divergent paths of Sam, Mike, Joe, and Mark mirror the complexities of both family dynamics and corporate aspirations.

Sam and Mike, the elder brothers, found their footing within the U-Haul framework, embracing their roles in the company. Their competence and dedication showcased their ability to navigate the demands of the business world. However, their relative success did little to alleviate the brewing tensions within the family.

Joe and Mark, on the other hand, bore the scars of unresolved traumas from their past. These lingering wounds manifested in their struggles to find their place in both the family and the business. Joe’s departure from U-Haul in 1979, along with Mark and Mike, marked a turning point. This rift in the family’s unity exposed the fragility of their relationships and demonstrated the challenges of merging personal bonds with corporate endeavors.

The departure of Joe, Mark, and Mike was emblematic of the clash between individual aspirations and the desire to preserve a united family legacy. The differing paths of the four siblings underscore the complexities of navigating familial expectations, personal ambitions, and the realities of the business landscape.

LS’s Complex Marital History

L.S. Shoen’s personal life was a tapestry woven with a series of marriages, divorces, and entanglements that mirror the broader themes of instability and shifting allegiances. L.S.’s romantic liaisons and marriages created a backdrop of complexity against which the family’s fortunes and the U-Haul business played out.

His early marriage to Anna Mary, despite her delicate health, signified his willingness to forge a life together despite challenges. However, the premature loss of Anna Mary in 1957 set in motion a series of events that would redefine L.S.’s marital journey. This poignant loss became a pivotal juncture, influencing L.S.’s subsequent choices and relationships.

L.S.’s unions with various women, including Suzanne Whitmore and Janet Hammer, illustrated the complexities of merging personal lives while tending to familial responsibilities. Only his fifth marriage to Carol Copeland stood out as a turning point, bringing a semblance of stability to his tumultuous romantic history. This union not only provided a more settled personal life for L.S. but also facilitated a stronger bond with the Shoen children, aiding in the family’s attempts to mend fissures caused by earlier conflicts.

Power Struggle and Decline

The desire for control among the siblings, particularly Joe and Mark, ignited a power struggle within the family. L.S. Shoen’s attempt to reconcile the diverging interests within the family by appointing Joe as chairman and Sam as CEO was intended to bring stability. However, this decision inadvertently exacerbated tensions. Joe’s ascent to the role of chairman triggered a power struggle characterized by competing visions for the company’s direction and leadership.

The dynamic between Joe and Mark, on one side, and L.S. and Sam, on the other, epitomized the broader themes of generational friction and differing approaches to business management. Joe and Mark’s challenges in embracing the legacy of their family’s enterprise and L.S. and Sam’s desire to protect their vision of the business led to heated confrontations and a climate of internal strife.

This tumultuous period marked the decline of both family harmony and the business’s stability. The shift in power from L.S. to Joe ultimately expedited L.S.’s retirement, signifying a changing of the guard and an uncertain future for both the Shoen family and U-Haul.

Suffering, Turmoil, and Demise

Joe’s campaign for control of U-Haul resulted in Sam’s resignation and widened family divisions. Physical confrontations, exemplified by the altercation between Joe and Mark during a shareholders’ meeting, exemplify the culmination of simmering tensions. This public display of discord serves as a stark visual representation of the family’s internal turmoil and division. The narrative captures the visceral emotions and the erosion of bonds that such confrontations can provoke.

Tragedy strikes when Eva, Sam’s wife, is murdered. This event casts a shadow of suspicion and grief over the family, revealing the depths of pain and turmoil they are experiencing. The loss of Eva further deepens the fractures within the family, intensifying the sense of loss and despair that had been steadily growing.

The financial difficulties faced by U-Haul mirror the instability within the family, illustrating the interconnectedness of personal and professional challenges. This confluence of adversities ultimately leads to the family’s detachment from the business they had built, representing the ultimate culmination of a once-prominent dynasty’s downfall.